In 1930, Dizzy Dismukes provided his list of the greatest outfielders he had seen during his 20 years as a Negro League pitcher, to The Pittsburgh Courier, as part of a series of ‘releases’ he wrote for the paper:
“From 1909 to 1915 I had seen a great array of outfield talent, including such stars as Pete Hill, Frank Duncan, Jap Payne, Spotwood Poles, Jimmy Lyons, (Robert ‘Judy’) Gans, C. B. Earl [sic Earle]…and a host of others.”
Dismukes
Dismukes said none of them measured up to the man who “I have little doubt that the choice of ranking him as no. 1 will be unanimous,” among The Courier’s readers:
“Ranking as the best outfielder of all time is Oscar Charleston, who reported to C. I. Taylor for a tryout in the spring of 1915 as a pitcher”
Dismukes said Charleston played some games in the outfield for Taylor and:
“His uncanny judgement of fly balls, his prowess with the bat, and daring on the bases in games he played soon convinced C. I. that he had about the best outfielder he had ever lamped.”
Charleston
Dismukes said:
“In the days of the bunt—that is the swing bunt—he excelled, and then, as the home run craze began to creep into the game, he kept pace with the leaders by amassing as many as any other.”
In the field, Dismukes said:
“Opposing players complained that four men played the outfield for the (Indianapolis) ABC’s. Charleston, playing close in behind second base, snared line drives which ordinarily were hits, and then when some batter would drive one to the far corners of the lot for what seemed like a sure hit, Charleston would bob up from somewhere to make a catch just before the ball had a chance to hit the ground. I for one have never seen his equal.”
Dismukes chose Pete Hill for number 2 all time:
“A close student of the game in every sense, he played the batter when playing outfield; was a great hitter in a pinch, whether it was a single, double, triple, or home run that was needed.”
The third best outfielder, according to Dismukes, was Jimmy Lyons:
“He too, like Charleston, broke in as a pitcher, but the late Dick Wallace, then manager of St. Louis (1911) realized his value as an outfielder. Lyons was the most daring of all batters I ever saw; was fast and used his speed to every advantage. He was considered about the freshest kid to break into baseball during those days. Safe bunting was his specialty. Talkative, he could upset an infield by telling them what he was going to do and get away with it…In that respect I class him as greater than Charleston or Hill. Drop the ball and he would run—and how.”
Dismukes said “that seemingly slow moving Frank Duncan” was number four:
“There was a natural hitter. A great judge of pitched balls and uncanny at getting to first base by being hit by a pitched ball. Frank’s position was left field. Hit one right on the foul line and he was there to receive it; hit one over the shortstop’s head, he was there; hit one up against the fence, he was there; why, how, everybody who has seen him play still wonders.”
Dismukes said “that nervous type” Spotwood Poles was fifth:
“(He) was the fastest man I ever saw in getting to first base. With all his speed however, he was an ordinary base runner, seemingly awkward, but a good fly chaser and one of the game’s greatest lead off men. And, truly, he was a great hitter.”
Next was Andrew “Jap” Payne:
“Payne in the time of need could do more acrobatic stunts to help a pitcher out of a tight situation, than all the outfielders put together. Almost any ball Jap could get within three to five feet of before hitting the ground he caught, as he usually took a dive for them.”
Payne
Dismukes’ next choice was Poles’ Lincoln Giants teammate Robert “Judy” Gans, who had become an umpire:
“(Gans’) whom his teammates dubbed ‘telegram’ because he told everything he knew, must be given credit for being one of the game’s greatest fielders. He started as a pitcher, but found his real greatness would be shown in the outfield.”
In the eighth spot:
“I had heard a lot of a lad out east by the name of (Herbert ‘Rap’) Dixon, and it was my good fortune to see him last fall in about seven games and I quickly concluded he was just about all I had heard of him. Eastern critics have been ranking him with Charleston. He is a great fly chaser, a hard and timely hitter, and few outfielders have possessed throwing arms the equal of his. To exclude his name from my list would be an injustice.”
And, “Last but not least” Dismukes said:
“James Bell, affectionately called by his teammates ‘Cool Papa’…I would like to see a contest with ‘Cool Papa’ as a participant (against the 1916 version of) Jimmy Lyons.”
Baseball History Daily 