Dizzy Dismukes probably wrote more about the players he saw during and after his career than any other Negro League player. The Pittsburgh Courier regularly published his observations in 1930. Like this one:
“Strolled into a barber shop (in St. Louis) a few days ago and arguments were rife as to the best pitcher of all times.”
Dismukes
Dismukes said that each participant in the discussion “based his argument on one particular game” they had witnessed. He told the group he would share his top nine “I had seen during my 21 years” in the pages of the paper:
“I’ve seen some might fine work done by some pitchers whose names won’t be included in the list because of the short duration of their performances. For instance, there was Bill Lindsay, who died early in his career (at age 23 in 1914), Pat Dougherty, who had as much zip on a fast ball as any pitcher who ever through a pellet, he imbibed too much of intoxicants, and numerous others.”
Dismukes said “consistency of performance for a reasonable number of seasons” was his criteria. Unfortunately, Dismukes chose not to go into the detail he did when selecting outfielders, or The Courier did not give him the space, so the pitcher list lacks a lot of the insights of the previous one, but listed them in order:
“Here goes:
-
Rube Foster
-
Cyclone Joe Williams
-
John Donaldson
-
Steel Arm John Taylor
-
Bullet Rogan
-
Dick Redding
-
Frank Wickware
-
String Bean Williams
-
Walter Bell”
Rube Foster
Of the list, he said:
“I’ve selected them in the order as their greatness appeals to me. There will be very little opposition to the placing of the first names two, although some may prefer juggling numbers 3, 4, 5, and 6.
“Some might argue as to the effect the lively ball would have had on their performances. In the list above are two notable examples: In the list above are two notable examples: ‘Cyclone’ Williams and Rogan. How many times during a season were they shelled off the hill?”
Next, he rated catchers. Josh Gibson, then 18, had not yet begun his first season with the Homestead Grays, and was not on Dismukes’ radar:
“The crop of young catchers breaking into the game in the past ten years have been so poor that I can only find three, namely: Frank Duncan, of the Kansas City Monarchs, Raleigh (Biz) Mackey of Hilldale, and Larry Brown of the Memphis Red Sox showing enough skill to qualify.”
His first choice:
“Topping the list is none other than Bruce Petway, whom I claim to be the greatest catcher I ever saw. His best days were spent during the base-running craze. There were not as many fast me afoot playing baseball then as now but there were more base runners. One could possibly count all the thefts against Petway during a season on one hand and then have a few fingers left.”
Dismukes said some people thought Petway was a poor catcher because he dropped a lot of balls, but he claimed:
“Petway would intentionally drop balls to encourage base runners to start, as very few had the nerve.”
Dismukes said Petway was a great base runner and “an uncanny judge” of foul pop ups.
Second was George “Chappie” Johnson:
“With Chappie behind the plat, a pitcher did not have to have much on the ball…(and he) was the greatest conversationalist in baseball…Chappie had the opposing batters dumbfounded with a never-ceasing flow of ‘lingo’ crossing the batter up by telling him exactly what the pitcher was about to deliver then standing far to one side of the plate telling the pitcher to ‘get this one over.’ The pitcher then shot one across the plate and he gracefully reached in with one hand to receive a strike. He excelled in receiving with one hand. Many young catchers have ruined a career trying to emulate Chappie.”
The third pick was Pearl “Specs” Webster:
“He could do everything expected of a great catcher. In competition he proved the fastest runner in colored baseball and in bunting and getting to first base as well as circling the bases he was a wonder. He truly was one of baseball’s greatest catchers. Specs died overseas in the service of the USA.”
Next was “a scrawny kid from Kansas City,” Frank Duncan:
“He gets the call for No. 4 position. A great receiver, thrower, fast on bases, and a dangerous hitter.”
Dismukes’ next choices:
“Pete Booker, another of the old school, gets post No. 5, while Russell Powell, reporting to the Indianapolis ABC’s as an infielder and converted into a catcher, is choice No. 6. He was one of the few catchers who seldom made false moves back of the plate. When he threw at a base runner there was always a chance of getting him. He excelled in trapping runners off third base with snap throws.”
His seventh choice:
“Wm. McMurray, who could look at batter’s feet and come near telling what batter could or could not hit, gets the lucky No. 7 position…whenever you put Mac in a game you always had a well-caught game.”
His final two choices were Biz Mackey and Larry Brown:
“(Mackey) a super hitter, and one who comes near as any recent catcher in having a throwing arm resembling that owned by the one and only Petway, in No. 8 in line, while ninth, last but not least is Larry Brown, who shows unusual skill in handling of pitchers. (Dolf) Luque, formerly of the Cincinnati Reds and now with Brooklyn of the National League, praises Brown as being the best receiver he ever pitched to.”
Baseball History Daily 