In the month leading up to the 1944 season there were concerns about there being a season.
Ty Cobb told an Associated Press (AP) reporter that “the baseball men have a mission to perform” by keeping the game alive during the war, even if “it is played by old men.”
Cobb said:
“If worst comes to worst, I’d get back into the harness myself to help preserve it.”
Cobb
The thought took hold in some circles.
Nearly fifty-year-old Howard Ehmke, whose business making canvas tarpaulins was now making protective covering for naval warship guns, told The AP:
“I’ll be 50 in April and I’m pretty busy around here, but if baseball needs me, I’ll come running. I won’t say much about my arm, but I ought to be able to do something. The game was good to me when I was in it, and I feel I owe it something.”
The idea was shot down by baseball’s oldest manager.
Connie Mack said the idea was “all bunk.”
He told The Philadelphia Record:
“We don’t need them; we don’t want them; I doubt if any of them wants to come back, and they can’t play anymore anyway. I’d much rather keep the game going with 14 and 15-year-olds.”
Mack said he felt there were enough men classified as 4-F combined with those not yet drafted and those too young to serve to carry on.
And he didn’t spare any of the former greats who suggested they might be willing to come back:
“It’s a joke to talk about such men as Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, Eddie Collins, Babe Ruth, Walter Johnson, and Al Simmons making comebacks.
“We appreciate the fine spirit they have shown to help baseball, but they can’t play now. Once a man has passed 35 or 40 and then gives up the game for a year or so, he can’t come back.”
Mack
Mack said he “pitied” the old-timers he watched play in a war bond game the previous summer.
“Great outfielders like Speaker—one of the finest flycatchers of all time—looked pitiable. I was afraid he would get hit on the head.”
Besides, said Mack, all fans cared about baseball, not the caliber of the game, and kids and 4-F’s could carry the load:
“They don’t look for super-excellence these days.”
Baseball History Daily 