Before the 1925 season, Billy Evans, the American League umpire and syndicated columnist, said St. Louis Cardinals pitcher Allan Sothoron was:
“One of the most mysterious cases in baseball.”
Evans said the 32-year-old who had spent parts of nine seasons in the major leagues:
“Here was a pitcher who was recognized as one of the richest prizes ever found. He had a fast ball, a spitter, a curve, a change of pace; control—well, just everything that a great pitcher requires.
“And Sothoron lived as a pitching star, but not for long. A weakness was discovered. Show the opposing side a weak spot and it plays through it.
“Sothoron, with an iron arm are rare intelligence, could not control his throw once he fielded the ball.”
During five seasons in the American League from 1917-1921, Sothoron made 50 errors in just 356 total chances.
“On bunts or easy taps hit straight to him he lost his bearings. With one swish of his arm, he threw—threw in any direction which usually was yards away from his fielder.
“To first, second, third base or the plate, Sothoron aimed and fired.
“And eventually, he threw himself out of the American League.”
Evans said Indians manager Tris Speaker “thought he could correct the fault’ when he acquired Sothoron in June of 1921, and for a time he thought he had–Speaker told The Cleveland News when he acquired the pitcher that the problem was Sothoron “throwing flat-footed.”
He won 12 and lost four, with a 3.24 ERA for Cleveland—although he did commit four errors in just 36 total chances. But in 1922, Speaker “gave up the job” after Sothoron appeared in just six games—he was 1-3 with a 6.39 ERA and made one error on six chances.
Evans said after he was released by Boston:
“Sothoron, disgusted with himself, retired from baseball.”
He returned to baseball in 1923, with the Louisville Colonels in the American Association. Despite a 6-9 5.92 season with the Colonels, Evans said:
“The scene changes. Branch Rickey, as manager of the St. Louis Browns in 1914, discovered Sothoron. And he refused to believe that such an evil could not be corrected. He took a chance and purchased Sothoron for his St. Louis Cardinals in 1924.”
And the pitcher responded:
“The story is not closed. Sothoron was one of the few pitchers with a perfect fielding average in the National league last season.”
He was 10-16 with a 3.57 ERA, but handled 37 total chances without an error, which included “making 35 perfect throws in aiding in the retirement of batters or runners.”
Evans attributed Sothoron’s fielding to:
“Branch Rickey’s system of training… (Rickey) saw that Sothoron…simply scooped in the ball and made his throw. He did not steady himself.
“For days and weeks, Sothoron was put through such a course—fielding a ball, pausing, steadying himself, then following through with the throw.”
Evans suggested that “after 10 years of drifting” Sothoron had “finally found himself.”
It did not last.
He pitched for the Cardinals for two more seasons, he was 13-13 with a 4.09 ERA, and he committed five errors in just 31 chances. He finished his career with an .871 fielding percentage.