William G. Nunn was city editor, and later, managing editor of The Pittsburgh Courier. He wrote a regular baseball column “Diamond Dope” for the paper throughout the 1920s, and later he would on occasion also write a sports column for paper called “WGN Broadcasts.”
.In 1934, he told a story about how “Gentleman” Dave Malarcher managed his Chicago American Giants:
Malarcher
“Chicago was sporting a small lead going into late innings. A Crawford player, with a man on first knocked a slow roller to (Jack) Marshall, keystone-sacker of the Windy City team. Marshall failed to field the ball in a hurry and loafed the throw to first base, with the result that all hands were safe.
“From the bench came running Dave Malacher, present manager of the team and one of the most astute diamond students Negro baseball has ever produced. We noticed a whispered conference.
After the game we asked Dave what it was all about. ‘I fined him five dollars,’ said Dave. ‘Fans come out here to see a ballplayer hustle at all times, ‘he continued, ‘and when he fails to do that, he’s hurting Negro baseball.
“Give us some more of that type of management. We don’t have any too much use for these all-star teams anyway. They look like a million dollars on paper, and like buns when they face real competition.”
Eight years later Nunn was a key figure in The Courier’s push—along with The Daily Worker— to integrate professional baseball. Nunn and his sports editor, Hall of Famer Wendell Smith attempted to broker a deal for four Negro League players to try out with the Pittsburgh Pirates. The Chicago Defender said in August of 1942:
William G. Nunn Sr.
“The four Negro baseball players to receive a tryout with the Pittsburgh Pirates the latter part of this month or first of September will be named next week.
“Three weeks ago William Benswanger, owner of the Pirates, stated that he was willing to give Negro players a tryout…Wendell Smith and William G. Nunn will confer with officials of the Negro American and National Leagues here (at the East-West Game)…and select the four players.”
Smith and Nunn, in collaboration with Negro League magnates, chose Josh Gibson, Leon Day, Sam Bankhead, and Willie Wells to receive tryouts.
Smith called Benswanger “The greatest liberal in baseball history,” at the end of August. The accolades were premature. The tryouts were never scheduled.
Baseball History Daily 